The Awkward One: Boss’s Day

The Awkward One: Boss’s Day


Boss’s Day is Friday, October 16, and it’s the one occasion on the appreciation calendar that people are openly ambivalent about.

The discomfort is legitimate and worth naming. Appreciation that flows upward, on a scheduled date, from people whose compensation the recipient controls, is structurally different from appreciation that flows any other direction. It can read as obligation at best and currying favor at worst — and everyone in the room, including the manager, knows it.

So the honest version of this post isn’t “here’s how to celebrate your boss.” It’s: this only works under certain conditions, and it’s worth knowing what they are.

Participation has to be genuinely optional

If someone organizes a card and walks it around the office while standing there, everyone signs. That’s not a signal. A manager who receives a card signed by 100% of their reports learns nothing from it, because there was no way to decline.

Something people can quietly opt out of produces a much more meaningful result, and — this is the part that surprises people — usually gets more sincere messages, not fewer.

Specific, or don’t bother

“Thanks for being a great manager” is the sentence that makes this occasion feel hollow. It’s the thing you write when you’re writing because you have to.

The alternative is a specific decision that affected you: the time they took the blame for a miss in front of the VP, the reorg where they fought to keep the team together, the week they told you to go home and stop working. Those aren’t flattery. They’re evidence, and evidence reads differently.

Good managers get almost no feedback

Worth remembering: management is one of the few jobs where the people best positioned to evaluate your work are the ones with the least incentive to tell you the truth about it. A manager who’s genuinely doing well often has no idea, because the feedback channel is jammed by the power difference.

A specific note from someone who didn’t have to write one is one of the only ways that information gets through.


If your team wants to do this, a group card handles the mechanics reasonably: people write on their own, opt out silently if they want, and it arrives once rather than as a parade of individual emails. Just keep it voluntary — that’s the whole thing.

Start one at cardjoy.app.